A week-old decomposing body was found in the bathroom of a hospital. The second this week. Weird, considering that even gas stations are required to clean their bathrooms every half hour. And then we learned that Hungarian hospitals are only required to clean them every other day.
Still, a week-old corpse is an outlier of which two seem like a new trend.
Hírcsárda, the Hungarian Onion was quick with the headline “Living body was found in a Hungarian hospital – Investigation in progress” and everyone understood. Whenever the discussion of healthcare is unavoidable people are half-joking that if you find yourself in a hospital it’s already too late. But it was a long process. It all started with free and universal (and unsustainable) healthcare promised under communism.
Sometimes a patient is treated with broken arms but dies from a stomach bug caught in the hospital, or a child ends up on breathing support because therapy-resistant bugs infected him during a routine tonsillectomy.
“1001 doctors who don’t accept gratitude money”, February 2016
Oliver Stone, myth maker and activist, was kind enough to suck up to the dictator Fidel Castro who destroyed his country in the name of communism. One of Stone’s many sins is presenting the state-sponsored Cuban healthcare system as superiour. US public debate appears to be polluted by this myth. So let me give you a few very representative stories from recent news on how the universal and “free” healthcare system plays out in the long run. And just how expensive it is. In money and in human lives.
- Anonymous whistle blower complaining that he routinely had to dilute disinfectant and re-use single-serving tools at work.
- Pediatricians are a dying breed – the average age of practitioners is 59 years.
- Over 800 women of Tatabánya signed a petition protesting against the shortage of doctors at the gynecological department at the local hospital because routine pregnancy tests now have months-long waiting lists (!) Good luck with the petition though.
- Hungary amputates three times as many limbs as the EU-average. Looking into the mystery it turned out that the central social security budget pays more for those than reconstructive surgeries. Same goes for C-sections.
- In 2014, avoidable hospital infections killed more people than car accidents. When the official 2015 data came out, however, it was so shiny, it put Hungary at the top of the world, statistically. Too bad, it didn’t make much sense.
- When the issue of nurses’ appallingly low wages came up the minister could only say “Don’t they have husbands?” at the press conference. This, after he was informed on the spot by a journalist how much nurses actually make.
- Bring your own medicine, gauze, lunch and a family member as nurse if you are to come to a hospital…
- …and considerable bribes – or they won’t even look at you in some cases. Some types of healthcare workers have adapted and learned to thrive under the system of expected “gratitude money”. They even have their price lists published. In case you wonder who within the medical profession is lobbying for this misery to continue.
- Government’s great idea to tackle the problem of gratitude money? You guessed it: they now allow doctors to pay taxes from it. (Clearly, we have very different definitions of the problem – the government and I.)
- The group “1001 doctors who don’t accept gratitude money” wrote in February 2016:
There are hospitals where even sterilization has stopped, the toilet cannot be flushed, patients cannot be isolated, there are no clean diapers, disinfectant, and the management cancels cleaning because there is no money for it.
Doctors also demand the publication of real statistics regarding the system because they no longer believe the official numbers, and to remove the supervisory authority from under ministry supervision. Again, the stupefying centralisation efforts of the Orbán-government don’t just dissolve education – they also claim lives.
Hungarians are used to universal free healthcare – as a communist relic. Today we get to see the last days of the system: it became corrupt, lethal, and very expensive. And by very expensive I mean out of pocket – and on top of the social security contributions.
An exodus of underpaid doctors and nurses, who’ve emigrated by the thousands to richer western European countries in recent years, has left behind overworked and underpaid colleagues at state hospitals. Hungarian governments have chipped away at health care spending, bringing public financing to 10 percent of budget spending by 2013, the lowest level among 34 OECD members. Partly as a result, Hungary has the highest mortality rate from cancer, and the lowest number of CT and MRI scanners among OECD countries.
And indeed, the government is perfectly free to not fund hospitals. Nurses and doctors are not allowed to strike – not that they could without immediately letting patients die. And when a nurse started wearing black to demonstrate against the death machine hospitals have become – she had been harassed and eventually fired for speaking up and being pesky. When she organised a very tiny protest on a bridge for 5 minutes she was ordered to do public work. The same week(s) taxi drivers have blocked the city for days to protest competition. (The thousands of taxi drivers did not get sent to do public work, just in case you were wondering. Government banned Uber for them.)
Obscenely, the government cannot stop funding football stadiums and international sports events, such as the 2017 FINA world championship (4 times over budget as of today) and an already shockingly expensive application for the 2024 Olympic games. And no, the comparison is not demagogic. Even the emergency reserved of the budget go into stadiums these days. And when 50% of your salary is taken in taxes, and free and universal healthcare is promised in return, it is your business whether stadiums or disinfectants are bought.
Free and universal healthcare seemed to work for a while, but eventually they ran out of money and can’t even borrow anymore. Hungarians ended up paying twice for a service of declining quality: once in social security, and once in bribes.
Or they may go to private hospitals – also out of pocket.
The lack of government investment has forced Hungarians — accustomed to universal health-care coverage since communist times — to dig deeper into their pockets. Private spending made up 35 percent of total health spending by 2013, the highest level in central Europe. Much of that has been so-called “gratitude payments,” money slipped by patients to doctors and nurses at state hospitals in hopes of getting better treatment.”
In 2016, the government had the marvelous idea of building a massive private hospital.
Bloomberg is rightly delighted to see private investment into a private hospital in Budapest – but there are three caveats:
- It is not private, it is crony.
- An early bird private hospital has been pushed out of the market – possibly in preparation of this ‘private’ investment.
- The lethal state of state healthcare will indeed push people into the shiny new hospitals. But they will still be made to pay a large chunk of their salaries into the social security budget.
In short, this is the way to give private healthcare a bad name. It will inevitably stoke resentment against “capitalism”. Not against the previous, unsustainable system that was outrageously mismanaged, nor against cronyism. People will blame private healthcare. And the next populist will inevitably agitate for free healthcare again – because that will be the public sentiment to ride.
As a wise celebrity once managed to say, hospitals don’t bring the nation together…
Meanwhile, in a Bristol hospital…
Data source: European Health Powerhouse Index (pdf)
Follow us on Facebook , Twitter @_MwBp , or subscribe to newsletter