Analysis

Why Orbán Cannot Retreat on CEU

A few things to watch out for in the Orbán vs. CEU war:

I’ve been saying this for a long time: The opposition cannot defeat Orbán. But Orbán can defeat himself. He think so, too. He reminded his followers many times that any lapse in paranoia can lead to a sense of false security – and thus to losing. He lost in 2002 exactly because of such a lapse in caution. He never forgot that lesson.

But there are things in his way of exercising power that set him up to exactly this kind of failure. Firstly, he has a constant need for confrontation. He thrives in it. He picks his own fights. He is better at it than any other politician (and I do not wish the others to get any better). Secondly, there is his complete detachment and lack of feedback from the outside world. He is known to be irritated with naysayers and critiques, and surrounded himself with only a handful of people who would only ever say yes. No one else can talk to him. Lastly, he cannot handle defeat, Any retreat, no matter how small or how rational, provokes an insatiable desire to strike back. And that is when he makes mistakes.

So when Momentum, a youth movement, defeated his Olympic dreams out of the blue – I reached for the popcorn. He was clearly unprepared. He was clearly furious. Momentum sneaked through the cracks – as evidenced by the fact that even the Fidesz propaganda machine took weeks to dig up some (lame) dirt on them. And Fidesz was slow to deliver its usual communication flash bomb to distract from that fiasco.

This is a crucial battle for Orbán. Not because of a university, but because of his hurt pride. He may have miscalculated the risk – especially the risk of the international waters into which he threw a stone with Lex CEU.

5 reasons Orbán cannot give up this fight:

  1. He already said things that would be hard to take back – as even CEUs rector admitted.
  2. Worse, even, he had recently lost a battle he didn’t know he was having. They were so confident about hosting the 2024 Olympics despite people’s concerns – they were taken by surprise when a new movement mobilized public opinion against them.
  3. This has been the biggest incident to this date. It is in an row of retreats – all bigger and more consequential then the one before:
    1. Orbán had to let go his favourite president over a plagiarism scandal – even though he really didn’t want to. But that guy was only symbolic.
    2. They had to retreat from their plans to tax the internetz. But that was just a (stupid) plan to collect more money, not an ideologically motivated move. They went on to tax something else.
    3. He had to withdraw the Sunday closure of retail stores because it was so unpopular, it threatened to give the opposition a winning referendum question. He had a lot of skin in this game, the subject aggravated so many for so long, Orbán bathed in it. Bullying a whole country with something so petty just because he could do it – that’s an autocrat’s way to silence potential future dissent and trigger the sense of helplessness.
    4.  He had to let go of the Olympics a few weeks ago.
  4. After that, Orbán simply cannot afford to lose another battle. He picked this fight right now, and he cannot retreat on something he so openly demanded.
  5. This may not even be his own idea. He hates Soros for sure. But the closure of the CEU along with the Russian-style foreign agent law proposed right after Lex CEU are clear Russian influences.

And why it might backfire:

His desperation to meet Trump seems to be innate – not suggested by Russians. He may seriously believe that his time has come the day the US elected an ethnic populist and economic protectionist as president. The wording of Lex CEU and the following government interviews all confirm that he now wants Trump to finally meet him. But…

  1. Trump may or may not be willing to expose himself with yet another Russian stooge.
  2. And the timing couldn’t be worse. Even if the Putin-Trump constellation would be in Orbán’s favour, it seems to be dissolving after the bombing of Syria. Which soured the much hoped for US-Russia reconciliation on Russia’s terms.
  3. Soros may be every autocrat’s favourite scapegoat, but American universities elsewhere in the world would also come under fire if CEU were let go easily.
  4. Orbán’s Fidesz is a member of EPP in the European Parliament. It is his main use for Putin as well as his main point of influence, because EPP serves as an opportunity to meet European leaders. Even those, who find him too toxic to meet one-on-one. Losing that opportunity might sideline Orbán in Europe.

Follow us on Facebook , Twitter @_MwBp , or subscribe to newsletter

Advertisements

One thought on “Why Orbán Cannot Retreat on CEU

  1. Pingback: Hungarian Spring? | Meanwhile in Budapest

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s