Guest Post

Forget Orbánism – It should be called Goulash Putinism

Orbánism – if there is such a thing – is more Putinism Light than an American-style culture war.

There is a misconception that there is such a thing as Orbánism. But if that was true, it would mean that Orbán possesses any original thought. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Throughout his whole career the one thing consistent – besides the aim for power for himself and wealth for his family – is his adaptation of any method securing the above.

As I wrote a couple of years ago:

Viktor Orbán has been labeled many things, ranging from freedom fighter to savior of Christian Europe, a neo-fascist dictator, and a populist. He is Europe’s most talented shape-shifter. Throughout his 30-year  political career he has been a long-haired liberal, a pro-EU conservative in a three-piece suit, and now a nationalist, immigrant-bashing grandfather, fighting what he calls the Brussels bureaucracy.”

Since then he has progressed to gay-bashing, and some drew comparison between Orbán’s and Putin’s anti-gay laws.

Those who follow Russian politics might find the recent trends in Hungary slightly familiar to this and this albeit in a lighter form. Orbán may be trying to import his “Kulturkampf” from the US, but his way of governing is lighter version of Putin’s.

The Imitation Game

Putin may have imitated liberal democracy, but his originality lays in the fact that he has created a dictatorship, masked it as a democracy complete with check and balances. All the institutions one can find in a real democracy is present in Russia, it’s just how they work that is different. The only original thing about Orbán’s system is that he has managed to create it in a country which is a member of the EU.

After the bloody repression of the 1956 revolution, through the following thirty years, Moscow’s man János Kádár morphed from a Quisling into a grandfather figure in many peoples’ yes. During his rule, Hungary (together with Yugoslavia) enjoyed a higher standard of living and greater freedoms than any other communist country. Goulash communism, as it became known, was mainly financed by support from the Soviet Union and western loans.

Kádár made it clear who was in charge and active opposition was persecuted and harassed. But the era of gulags and executions of real or perceived enemies was over. People who behaved were even permitted to visit western countries every third year.

For many Hungarians, Goulash Communism is still remembered as a golden era.

In his almost twelve years in power, Orbán has created a system similar to Putin’s. The hostile takeover of nominally independent institutions and businesses, the news media and rewriting the election rules are straight out of the Kremlin playbook.

Where Hungary differs from Russia is the scale of repression, corruption, and graft. Whereas Putin’s critics have a tendency of turning up dead or on the gulag, Orbán’s are just slandered by his media, and may receive an occasional tax audit. Business owners in conflict with Orbán have a chance to sell their businesses and walk free. The worst that can happen to someone is losing their job and business.

Demonstrations are still allowed and courts are still able to rule against the government in many cases.

Any Russian oligarch with self respect has his own private jet and boat, the Hungarian ones seem to share the same boat (although it has been upgraded to a bigger one) and take turns in using the same plane. Compared to their Russian counterparts the current Hungarian elite looks almost as puritan as their communist predecessor did in their time, matched against leaders like Brezhnev and Ceausescu.

The 2019 local elections showed that it’s still possible to win in certain places, and the upcoming 2022 general election is still more dangerous for Orbán than any election Putin stands to face in Russia.

In 1989 goulash communism collapsed due to financial and political bankruptcy. People were not content living in the happiest barrack in the Eastern bloc, they wanted to live in the West without having to leave Hungary.

Just like his communist predecessors, Orbán is painting the West as a decadent place heading into chaos. The question is when most of the Hungarian society will decide that being a slightly better place than Belarus in the middle of the European Union is not enough.

Orbán doesn’t deserve to have a system named after him because he has not created anything. Just like the communists, he has imported something foreign and adapted it to the Hungarian environment. Let’s call it by its real name: Goulash-Putinism.

Featured image: Facebook

2 thoughts on “Forget Orbánism – It should be called Goulash Putinism

  1. “Where Hungary differs from Russia is the scale of repression, corruption, and graft. Whereas Putin’s critics have a tendency of turning up dead or on the gulag, Orbán’s are just slandered by his media, and may receive an occasional tax audit. Business owners in conflict with Orbán have a chance to sell their businesses and walk free. The worst that can happen to someone is losing their job and business.”

    Welsz Tamás and Váradi András like this.

    OK, I get it: Welsz and Váradi are two isolated and suspicious cases from 2014 and not business as usual cases as we would consider them if they happened in Russia. Still, a precedent has been set. They dared to do it twice, they will resort to it again as soon as they run out of less radical methods. Murdering enemies is rare and very atypical, but not off-limits.

    Like

    • Agreed. The logic of these methods is the slippery slope. The more radical tools are not used while not needed but they may be later. The above quote implies that there is a stop on the slippery slope. A common fallacy. If it were true, no autocrat would deteriorate, ever, just find a stable point somewhere and be content with it. (This it the editor, the post was written by a guest author.)

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.